the nonconformist penguin and the Almighty Bob (newbia) wrote in anti_illiteracy,
the nonconformist penguin and the Almighty Bob

  • Mood:
  • Music:

In which we realize just how big of a geek Newbia really is.

((For clarification: I am a geek, not a dork or nerd.))

Do you know why Americans are accused of knowing less grammar than the rest of the developed world? No, it's not because the Brits are a bunch of stuck-up meanies. It is because we don't actually learn any grammar past elementary school.

Oh, we learned have "grammar lessons" of course, but we don't learn any grammar, because grammar means knowing how to speak and write well, "well" being judged according to a set of rules. All we learn in class is what all those words are called--prepositional phrases, infinitive forms. I shudder to think I saying "when will we ever have a use for knowing that in real life?" because when someone says that, 99% of the time there is a perfectly good reason that the person doesn't realize. [1] The reason is to make learning grammar clearer, because it would be fairly confusing for someone to tell you to always put a comma after a prepositional phrase at the beginning of a sentence when you don't know what a prepositional phrase is and think you're talking about apostrophes. [2] Problem is--we don't actually use what we learn in grammar, because we don't learn grammar!

Maybe it's just my school. In sixth grade, I attended a school in California and my teacher was the fabulous [name removed, henceforth known as "Edna"]. At the beginning of every grammar period she would put a sentence on the board and we would have to correct it. In that way, we learned to put the periods at the end of sentences, where apostraphes should go, not to say "like" or Edna would slap you, etc. Now that I look back on it, it's very basic stuff I learned in third grade--I had to figure out how to use an ellipsis all by myself. When I move to New Jersey, the teachers did not do that, even though the new school was actually a better one.

Every time my teacher (who is not fabulous) takes out the grammar book, I moan and groan like everyone else in the class. But if she would just teach us some frikkin' grammar, I would jump for joy.

[1] Speaking of perfectly good reasons--I have doing anything if it's not for a good reason, so every time I use a grammar rule I think of a reason for it. Guess what? You actually really do need grammar for many good reasons! Like, OMG! So, bring it on--tell me any rule, any rule at all, and I will tell you why it's needed. Seriously, please do. I am a geek, bordering on nerdiness.

[2] And, of course, because the teacher would get fired if she didn't teach what was in the basic curriculum.

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic
Woah, who knew?

I suppose you learn something new, everyday.

My experiences with grammar haven't been too entirely positive. Apparently, when I took an exam to get into the school, it said that I needed help with pronouns. And the teachers, up to seventh grade, were so bad. They didn't make sure everyone understood things, they just went over it once, and if you didn't get it the first time, it was too bad, because they had other things on the curriculum to teach. But, my seventh/eighth grade teacher was amazing, and made sure we understood the structure of the language. And, it helps me in other languages, as other languages help me to better understand grammatical structures in English, too.
We Brits don't get taught grammar properly either, it's not just an American thing, although the situation is improving. Children are learning to punctuate sentences properly about age 7 now, whereas we were taught what all the little squiggles did and what they were called but never really had any proper practice using them.

Everyone thinks I'm a geek as well, because a) I actually know and understand grammar and punctuation and b) I'm passionate about its importance and correct use.
The only reason I do know and understand grammar is because I did Latin at school, and we had to have a term's worth of lessons on English grammar before we could begin learning Latin grammar. If they could do that for the Latin students, then why not do it for all students? Why not produce a generation of children who can tell the difference between its and it's and who know what a clause is and where to put a comma? Hopefully that's what the 7-year-olds learning about punctuation will turn out to be. Hopefully. In the meantime I'll continue banging my head against the wall and going through my friends' essays with a red pen before they hand them in.